Three waterfront restaurants worth making a night of
From Manhasset Bay to the Great South Bay, choose the right waterside table for your occasion.
On Long Island, dinner by the water can mean very different things. A polished steakhouse overlooking a marina is a different evening from a long lunch on the South Shore. These three restaurants are worth considering because the setting is part of the experience, not simply a detail on the menu. Our picks are based on published restaurant information and local dining coverage, rather than firsthand visits.
Louie’s Prime Steak & Seafood, Port Washington
For a special occasion in Nassau County, start with Louie’s on Main Street. Its Manhasset Bay location makes it a natural choice for a birthday, anniversary or dinner with visitors from out of town. The restaurant traces its history to 1905 and today offers dry-aged steaks, a raw bar and sushi. Pick this when your group includes both steak and seafood lovers and you want a more dressed-up evening.
Ask about a water-facing table when booking; outdoor and window seating are never guaranteed. Arriving before sunset allows time to appreciate the harbor without rushing straight into dinner. The restaurant publishes a smart-casual dress code.
Louie’s website and menus · 395 Main Street, Port Washington.
The LakeHouse, Bay Shore
For South Shore residents, The LakeHouse is a compelling option when the occasion calls for a proper dinner rather than a quick bite. The restaurant has operated since 2006 and offers brunch, lunch and dinner, with a deck overlooking the bay. It is especially useful for a celebration where not everyone wants to drive to the North Shore.
Make a reservation and decide whether a daytime view or an evening meal is more important. Brunch can be a better fit for a multigenerational group, while dinner gives a smaller party time to linger.
The LakeHouse website · 135 Maple Avenue, Bay Shore.
Nicky’s on the Bay, Bay Shore
Save this one for warm weather. Nicky’s is a seasonal dockside restaurant with seafood and cocktails overlooking the Great South Bay. It suits a relaxed afternoon when the location matters more than formality. The restaurant currently says it will reopen in May 2027, so it is not a pick for this winter.
Nicky’s website · 150 South Clinton Avenue, Bay Shore.
How to choose
Choose Louie’s for a North Shore celebration, The LakeHouse for a South Shore sit-down meal, and Nicky’s for a casual in-season outing. Check current menus, weather and seating directly before traveling. A sunset reservation does not guarantee a sunset view: the orientation of the table, clouds and season all matter.